Announcement

Collapse

December's CHALLENGE

The topic to inspire your creative juices this month is BOXES

See more
See less

Which One?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Which One?

    Can you help…..I need to submit one of these images for a comp at the local camera club, the trouble is I’m really, really not sure which one I should enter .
    I would value some opinion from forum members.



    Pier1


    Pier2

  • #2
    Re: Which One?

    No 2 for me, I like the pattern of the steelwork. In fact I would crop the sky severely and present it in letterbox format.

    It follows, on my record, that no. 1 as shown is therefore the better option.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Which One?

      Hi Mike

      Number two for me also.

      Regards. Barr1e
      Just like that - gone in a flash! Now in use.

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Which One?

        I'd say #2 too. Seems that much sharper and greater contrast.
        E500 - E600 - E620 - HLD5 x2 - 17.5-45mm - 14-42mm - 14-45mm - Sigma 30mm f1.4 - 25mm f2.8 - 40-150mmMI (3.5) - Sirius 60-300mm f4-5.6 - Chinon 55mm f1.4 - Chinon 200mm f3.5 - FL50 - FL36 - Raynox DCR2020PRO

        http://www.flickr.com/photos/photonutter/

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Which One?

          Hi Neil

          I have a preferance for Pier1, I think the birds in the sky on Pier2 are a bit distracting. But I think the overall image in Pier1 is more appealing. Although it does seem a tad more soft. I think it gives a bit more than Pier2.

          Susan

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Which One?

            Number 1 for me as well.

            The colours beneath the pier and in the reflections and the lighting of the signs and the bulbs all give the image a lot more interest and as said the birds are a bit distracting in the 2nd

            However it is let down by the lack of the front of the building and the cut being part way through the dome - if you have more then use it - if not crop in a bit from the right until it looks straight

            Regards
            Andy
            Last edited by shenstone; 24th January 2009, 10:37 PM. Reason: spelling
            My Kit (OK I'm a hoarder...)
            4/3 E500, E510, E30 + 35macro, 50macro, 7-14, 11-22, 14-45 (x2), 14-54, 40-150 (both types), 50-200, 70-300, 50-500,
            m 4/3 EM1MkII + 60 macro, 12-100 Pro
            FL20, FL36 x2 , FL50, cactus slaves etc.
            The Boss (Mrs Shenstone) E620, EM10-II, 14-41Ez, 40-150R, 9 cap and whatever she can nick from me when she wants it

            My places
            http://www.shenstone.me.uk
            http://landroverkaty.blogspot.com/
            https://vimeo.com/shenstone
            http://cardiffnaturalists.org.uk/

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Which One?

              The first is far far better with a more interesting perspective and nicer reflections. I am certain that the first one would do quite well too (it would if I was judging............!)
              Dave

              E-M1 Mk2, Pen F, HLD-9, 17, 25, 45, 60 macro, 12-40 Pro, 40-150 Pro, 12-50, 40-150, 75-300, MC-14, MMF-3 (all micro 4/3rds), 7-14 (4/3rds), 50, 135 (OM), GoPro Hero 3, Novo/Giottos/ Manfrotto supports. Lowepro, Tamrac, Manfrotto, and Billingham bags.

              External Competition Secretary, Cwmbran PS & Welsh Photographic Federation Judge

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Which One?

                Number 1 for me.

                Its because the horizons visible below the pier and the angle of prespective is nicer.


                Well done.

                Ps the other one's nice as well
                All the best

                Being left handed my brain sometimes works sdrawkcab

                Andy

                Lots of cameras and lenses.


                My Flickr

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Which One?

                  I prefer No 1 but I think both of them look a little flat and could be improved by darkening the mid tones and upping the saturation a touch.

                  Ian C

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Which One?

                    I'm a number 1 fan as well - it gives the idea of length, and you've got the the three different textures of sea extending out on diagonals.

                    Number 2 is OK - but I'm distracted by the concrete abutments on the rhs, they don't form a finished shape.

                    Anyway there is something about the pier as an unanchored bridge in 1 that appeals.


                    Nick
                    Nick Temple-Fry

                    Medicine as a science ranks somewhere between archaeology and economics.

                    www.theChurchPhotographer.co.uk 90 Churches -- Fairford St Mary's, exceptionally splendid
                    www.temple-fry.co.uk

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Which One?

                      No1 for me also, more textures and interest. I might be tempted to crop the bottom just below the red reflection, just to strengthen the lines.
                      The picture tells the story, great when you have a bad memory.DW.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Which One?

                        No.1 for me, think the lights help lift theimage and the colours are better.
                        Glen
                        Cogito sumere potum alterum

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Which One?

                          No 1 for me. I like the reflections and find the foreground distracting on number 2. Also the perspective on no.2 seems strange, as though it was taken with a very wide angle lens.
                          Shirley
                          www.shirleyhollisenterprises.co.uk
                          www.photographsbyshirley.co.uk

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            #2 with the balloons N.T.

                            N.T. = No Text

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Which One?

                              No 2 but crop the top. Long things almost always look better in "Panoramic" format. Try a 16x9 crop

                              Graham

                              We often repeat the mistakes we most enjoy...

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X