PDA

View Full Version : Fisheye Lenses. Panasonic 8mm (m4/3) Vs Olympus 8mm


Alex G.
29th June 2014, 02:41 PM
Hi!

I am considering to get a fisheye lens (and have been considering for quite some time now).

Does anyone have any experience with using any of those 2 lenses? (Olympus 8mm 4/3, and Pana 8mm m4/3) any image samples as well?

Is it worth getting the olympus 4/3 since I have the mmf-3 converter or should i go for the pana m4/3 one which is a bit cheaper as well given that the lens will be mounted on my E-M1?


Thanks!

Graham_of_Rainham
29th June 2014, 03:06 PM
Hi,

Have you considered the Samyang 7.5mm MFT lens. It provides 180 FoV and is a lot cheaper.

Given the highly specialised nature of Fish-eye photography, unless it's something you will use a lot, it may well be worth considering hiring one from Ian, as and when you want it.

Have fun, and do please show us the end results.

*chr

StephenL
29th June 2014, 03:16 PM
I love the Samyang, and the fact it is manual focus (and diaphragm) is really irrelevant.

David M
29th June 2014, 03:21 PM
I like my Samyang because it is manual focus and aperture.

Alex G.
29th June 2014, 03:23 PM
I was considering the Samyang as well but the only thing that worries me is the build quality. It sure can't be anywhere near the build quality of the pana or oly (right?)

StephenL
29th June 2014, 04:05 PM
Wrong. Built like a brick dunnie.

yorky
29th June 2014, 04:50 PM
Now't wrong wi Samyang mate. Built like a brick outhouse.

pdk42
29th June 2014, 07:32 PM
Well, the Sammy might look like it's built like a brick sh1thouse, but if it's anything like their 14mm f2.8 for FF, then the reality might be different. I had that lens back in my Canon days and it felt similarly well built, but I had problems with the focus operation so took it apart. Inside the build quality was pretty rudimentary.

However, I must say that the 7.5mm MFT fisheye is a great lens optically and I've not had any particular problems with mine. It certainly doesn't suffer from the focus issues I had with the 14mm (which included very poor infinity calibration and severe backlash such that when the ring was set at a particular distance, the actual focus point varied enormously depending from which direction the focus ring was turned).

Over all though, hiven its price and performance, I'd certainly recommend it.

byegad
30th June 2014, 04:36 PM
I really like my Samyang 7.5mm. Excellent lens and really easy to use. Not sure I'd splash big money for an Automatic focus Oly or the very big spalsh out needed for the Pany. It's a specialised lens so only gets taken out fairly infrequently.

Alex G.
30th June 2014, 04:48 PM
Well I have to say I am convinced which is why I decided to get the Samyang. All of you seem to be happy with it so I believe I will be satisfied with it as well.

If the build quality and image quality is as good as you say then indeed there is no reason to spend 2 or 3 times more to get the oly or pana. and autofocus is not really essential, it being a fisheye lens.

Thank you all for your input here

byegad
30th June 2014, 05:45 PM
I'm sure that you'll like the lens, set to f8 it has a huge depth of field too.

Peter_Hartland
30th June 2014, 06:28 PM
The Samyang 7.5mm is excellent build quality & as others have said built like a tank. I know a number of foggers who have it one has ever complained about its quality. I think for the price you will be impressed.

Anne
1st July 2014, 12:19 PM
Another thumbs up for the Samyang. It's a great lens for the price; I have no problems with the build quality of mine or the IQ. In fact the only problem I do have is that I don't use it enough :)