View Full Version : Yellow roses

27th August 2008, 01:27 PM
I was trying to find a different composition when photographing these roses. Do you think any of these work? Critique welcome, as always.

Single rose from below

Selective focus

Head and shoulders above the rest

27th August 2008, 01:56 PM
The composition of the first one is good and posibly with some alternative positions within the frame may well work even better.

I'm not at all keen on the second. But if the technique was applied to the third composition I think you would have, overall, a really nice picture.

Shooting up on things is not often seen and any experimentation with alternate perspectives is always a good idea and a reminder to us all to try it.


27th August 2008, 09:52 PM
I have just posted these on the Four Thirds User site so I thought I would add them here as well.
Amended versions using lighting filter in Elements.



Thanks for looking

Bill Gordon
27th August 2008, 11:01 PM
Shirley, you are absolutely awesome!!

28th August 2008, 06:52 AM
Yes, I think the reworked versions are much better. Plus the background has been pushed more towards black (my favourite colour)


28th August 2008, 07:00 AM
Just love the first of the re-worked images. Its simple yet powerful. The stalk appear above the frame nicely balances this image. the impact of the colours against the background takes your breath away.
In a word. beautiful.

Thanks for sharing


The Judge
28th August 2008, 10:29 AM
The first image is clearly the best of the group. From a compositional point of view you have captured the subject very well. You mention you were trying to find a different composition and although there is nothing radical here, with this in mind you seem to have found the right angle for the shot. Full marks for this and well done.

Now the lighting in the amended version has served the subject well. It needed this because the rose did seem a tad dark. Yellow is associated with being a vibrant colour and there does seem to be a certain expectation around this. The link is the colour and the subject thus the whole image would improve by giving it some pop. The thing that has not worked for me is the swirly background. Maybe it is just my monitor not sure, but here it is distracting from an otherwise great image. My suggestion would be to lift the subject somewhat and deal with the harsh lit edges to the left and darken out the background.

All in all worthy of being in the perfection area here. The other images less so, they are not up to the same standard as your first shot and maybe best dealt with in a separate thread.